Subsidiarity and Federalism: An Old Concept with Contemporary Relevance for Political Society
نویسنده
چکیده
Introduction Historically human societies have never collectively organized, politically or socially, in any singular, standardized and/or universal way. Beginning with the Peace of Westphalia in 1647 the nation-state gradually proliferated as a legitimate manifestation of collective human organization at a global level. This proliferation has culminated in the standardization of a singular means of mobilizing and organizing human societies. The statist age that began in the 16 and 17 centuries consolidated and centralized the political power of the state. Divergent factions and regional power blocks within European states were discouraged, as politics became centralized at the national level. The proliferation of the nation-state represented the standardization of human political organization according to a single model. Given that there are, and have been, a variety of means by which humans identify and organize politically, this suggests that this universal acceptance and entrenchment of one model may be somewhat inappropriate. However, federal political systems offer the opportunity to accommodate these divergent political realities. In a federal political system governance and authority are held and exercised at different levels of government some powers are held by the central, national, government and some powers are held by the social and/or political units that are constituent parts of the whole nation. In so far as the world is organized into nations with a central, unitary, level of government which represents aggregate wholes of vast multitudes of communities it is doubtful that the nation-state model would have the capacity to accommodate for differences in cultures and political realities within
منابع مشابه
The Evolution of Canadian Federalism and its Possible Impact on Quebec Secessionist Discourse
It must be admitted that the current analysis of Canada’s contemporary federalism is very often negative. One of the main criticisms being mentioned by intellectuals is certainly the fact that the country is organized around an ideal of territorial federalism, while Quebec would rather see it evolve into a truly multinational dynamic.1 The clash between these two conceptions is important; while...
متن کاملA Comparative Study on the Concept of Political Legitimacy in Imam Khomeini and Jurgen Habermas's Thoughts
Political legitimacy is one of the basic and major concepts of political science especially political thought. Different views of the meaning and the concept of political legitimacy go back to the roots of political legitimacy. In this article by using a comparative style, the author will attempt to compare the concept of political legitimacy in Imam Khomeini and Jurgen Habermas's th...
متن کاملSubsidiarity and Robustness: Building the Adaptive Efficiency of Federal Systems
Subsidiarity—a systemic predilection for locating authority at the most local level feasible—has long been admired for its ability to protect localized, diverse interests from the tyranny of a national majority. In this article I suggest a novel benefit of subsidiarity: it boosts the adaptive efficiency of federal systems. To remain relevant, federal systems must adapt to meet changing circumst...
متن کاملComparative Study of the Concept of Justice in the Contemporary Political Philosophy of Islam and the West (With emphasis on Michael Sandel's votes)
The idea of Communitarianism with epistemic teachings, such as politics as virtue, the priority of good faith, respect for the cultural diversity of societies, is one of the most prominent intellectual currents of the present age. The hypothesis of this research is that based on the comparative analytical attitude of key societal teachings and the epistemic principles of Islam, one can find com...
متن کاملThe Economics of Multilevel Governance
This paper proposes a framework for analyzing governance in terms of centralization vs. decentralization of the provision of an order to a given community. It is the main tradeoff behind many issues related to the organization of the institutions that frame either political activities (constitution and federalism) or the economy (e.g. public vs. private/self regulation). We systematically analy...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2003